The government’s proposed superannuation performance test needs to be assessed on net returns and HESTA is questioning the reasons the government has chosen not to include fees in its metric.
The industry super fund’s submission to the Your Future Your Super legislation said the fund was not clear about the reasons the Government chose a metric to determine returns before administration fees had been deducted, while the possibility of including investment fees had been included in the draft bill.
“If the aim of the reforms is transparency and protection, it is crucial that all fee types be considered so that the end result is reflective of what members will receive in their accounts,” the submission said.
“Further, we encourage a more nuanced conversation about systemic underperformance rather than the blunt measures discussed in the budget announcement. It may be that from time to time, strong funds will underperform at the margins of the proposed measure. The proposed measure should consider systematic underperformance which might be evidenced over a longer period of time or a more material difference from the benchmark.”
HESTA said the time period proposed was not reflective of contemporary understanding of market cycles and that investment performance should be considered over a longer time period of 10 years.
The fund’s other concerns with the proposed benchmarks included:
The fund also noted it was concerned about the proposed treatment of unlisted assets in the benchmark.
It said the use of a listed index such as the FTSE Core Developed Infrastructure Index hedged to AUD was not an appropriate benchmark for unlisted infrastructure.
Reasons for the fund’s concerns included:
“This is one example of the ill-considered approach of using listed benchmarks to assess the performance of unlisted assets,” HESTA said.
“It will be to the detriment of the nation, and our economic recovery from the pandemic, if proposed benchmarks make unlisted infrastructure unattractive.”
A member of the super fund has approached ASIC to investigate potentially misleading or deceptive representations by UniSuper regarding the holdings of its sustainable portfolios.
The median growth fund delivered 1.9 per cent in March, adding to the “stunning” rally that has seen super funds gain 11 per cent since November.
Vanguard has affirmed its support for the current super performance test, emphasising the importance of keeping the process straightforward.
While some superannuation funds have gone down the route of internalisation, others say they favour ‘smart partnering’ with external managers for diversification appeal.
Add new comment